{
  "schema": "adfactory.bounded-review-adjudication/v1",
  "reviewModelRequested": "gemini-3.8-flash",
  "returnedModelIdConfirmed": false,
  "scope": "Research critique only; no owner approval or production quality pass.",
  "audio": {
    "input": "Three whole tracks A=targ B=film C=taras; 40kbps mono proxies; owner ranking not supplied",
    "transport": "HTTP 200; original receipt incomplete-review-outcome-unresolved; no finishReason/DONE",
    "recovery": "Complete JSON recovered offline, without a second POST. Original raw response and receipt retained.",
    "acceptedAsBoundedInterpretation": [
      "A/C described as conversational rhythmic pop/R&B singing, B as smoother lyrical pop singing; not authoritative genre classification.",
      "B ranked first for melodic expressiveness and CTA musical integration; A then C ranked above B for narrative immediacy. Single model opinion, not owner vote.",
      "C CTA is a rapid sung/spoken-sung closing tag; B continues a longer sung cadence. See actual endings."
    ],
    "rejectedOrUnverified": [
      "C strict 1:1 millisecond/near-note-for-note fidelity: contradicted by semantic landmark drift and unverified notes.",
      "B mentor Maryna: false; accepted text names Iryna.",
      "Invented quoted B phrase about neck: not in accepted lyrics; use actual lyrics and recording.",
      "Precise instrument identities, registers/notes and mix balance: not independently confirmed from the low-bitrate mono proxies.",
      "Exact onset milliseconds and arrangement change boundaries: model approximations, not frame-accurate measurements.",
      "C higher syllable density globally: old measured per-minute averages are nearly identical for B and C; local phrasing may differ."
    ]
  },
  "av": {
    "targ": "Complete structured critique received, but local/global time-offset errors and uncertain visible text. Not a replacement for canonical shot passport.",
    "film": "Complete structured critique received, but several timecodes/scene claims wrong; no automatic full-resolution/skin/continuity pass.",
    "taras": "HTTP 524; unknown POST outcome; no full A/V critique delivered and no retry."
  },
  "manualEvidence": "Complete 1fps contact-sheet sequences inspected, selected full-resolution proof frames inspected; not continuous human playback or every-native-frame perceptual review.",
  "notCompleted": [
    "Expert full-resolution continuous audiovisual listening/viewing of C",
    "Every-breath and every-note manual annotation",
    "Error-free canonical adaptation shot/microevent passports",
    "Controlled generation test"
  ]
}